Syracuse men’s basketball: Joe Girard’s complicated tenure with the Orange
Mar 28, 2023 - 3:00 PMHow would you describe Joe Girard’s career with the Syracuse Orange men’s basketball team?
Underwhelming or underappreciated? It’s not an easy answer by any means.
For better or worse, it appears that Girard is moving on. He announced on Friday that he would be declaring for the 2023 NBA Draft while adding his name to this year’s transfer portal. Girard said he was keeping an option open to return to Syracuse, but he’s moving on to meetings with three schools so it seems as though his time with the Orange has ended.
Syracuse transfer @JG3_____ will have home visits with Coach Matta and Staff from Butler on Sunday, Coach Haase and Staff from Stanford on Monday, and Coach McMahon and Staff from LSU on Tuesday https://t.co/N3zimpItfx
— Adam Zagoria (@AdamZagoria) March 25, 2023
That begs the question: how should we remember Girard’s time with the Orange?
Most of the Orange fanbase can agree that the initial hype preceding Girard’s rookie season in 2019-2020 never quite panned out in the final product. For the most part, that’s what paved the way for such a back-and-forth. unclear debate around Girard. Was he supposed to be the next Gerry McNamara? If you look at the career per-40 minutes numbers, there isn’t a big difference statistically.
So what makes Girard such a divisive player among the Syracuse fanbase?
Part of it stems from his shift in roles over his career. Back in October, I went on the record to defend Girard’s productive 21-22 season, while also acknowledging my skepticism for his ability to increase his offensive workload. Outside of Jesse Edwards, I believed he was Syracuse’s second-most irreplaceable player.
This is where the conversation get interesting. While he did average career-highs in points per game and field goal percentage this past season while, he still struggled at inopportune times for a team that needed his veteran leadership. After a stellar 31-point outing against Richmond, Girard shot 2-25 in the next three games, all losses for the Orange. That stretch put Syracuse in a tough spot early in the season, one from which they never recovered.
The last shot against the Wake Forest game was the microcosm of Girard’s legacy: he was never meant to be a primary creator. He wasn’t really meant to be a point guard and he wasn’t really a fit for the 2-3 zone. Still he found a way to impact games and make some tough shots.
It’s disappointing to see how his career ended up. Look at his improvement offensively over his four years and you’ll see that he did grow as a player. Ideally, he would’ve been more successful had he played his natural position sooner in his Syracuse career, but the extra year of eligibility gives Girard an opportunity at a clean slate.
His Syracuse legacy is complicated but in time he’ll likely become more appreciated as so many Orange players before him have experienced.
Be the first!
Related News
- Syracuse men’s basketball: the Orange’s non-conference resume by the numbers Dec 26
- Syracuse football: Orange add transfer OL Josh Miller from Georgia Dec 23
- ‘Twas the Night Before Cusemas 2023 Dec 22
- Syracuse men’s basketball: three takeaways from the Orange’s win over Niagara Dec 22
- Syracuse men’s basketball: the Orange squeeze past Niagara 83-71 in final non-conference game Dec 21
- Game thread: Syracuse vs Niagara and Syracuse vs South Florida Dec 21
- Syracuse women’s basketball: the Orange trounce Saint Francis 85-43, finish 10-1 in non-con slate Dec 21
- Syracuse men’s basketball: predictions and poll vs Niagara Dec 21
- Syracuse men’s basketball: what to watch for vs Niagara Dec 21
- Syracuse women’s basketball: Weekly TNIAAM Awards and ACC Update for December 20th Dec 20
- Syracuse women’s basketball: three takeaways from the 78-71 win versus Cornell Dec 19
- Former Syracuse men’s basketball center Jesse Edwards out for West Virginia with broken wrist Dec 19