Regular Season

•  
  @
  Swansea City Swansea City
  1-0
  Swansea.com Stadium
•  
  vs
  Millwall Millwall
  1-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Middlesbrough Middlesbrough
  1-0
  Riverside
•  
  @
  Ipswich Town Ipswich Town
  5-0
  Portman Road Stadium
•  
  vs
  Charlton Charlton
  1-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Oxford United Oxford United
  1-0
  Kassam Stadium
•  
  vs
  Southampton Southampton
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Hull City Hull City
  1-0
  MKM Stadium
•  
  vs
  Watford Watford
  1-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Blackburn Blackburn
  3-1
  Ewood Park
•  
  @
  Preston North End Preston North End
  3-2
  Deepdale
•  
  vs
  Derby County Derby County
  3-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Coventry Coventry
  3-1
  Ricoh Arena
•  
  vs
  QPR QPR
  0-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
  3-0
  Hillsborough Stadium
•  
  vs
  Portsmouth Portsmouth
  3-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Leicester City Leicester City
  3-2
  King Power Stadium
•  
  vs
  Stoke City Stoke City
  4-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  vs
  Norwich City Norwich City
  1-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  West Bromwich Albion West Bromwich Albion
  2-0
  The Hawthorns
•  
  vs
  Birmingham City Birmingham City
  3-0
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Wrexham Wrexham
  5-3
  Racecourse Ground
•  
  @
  Stoke City Stoke City
  2-1
  bet365 Stadium
•  
  vs
  Leicester City Leicester City
  3-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Charlton Charlton
  1-0
  The Valley
•  
  @
  Southampton Southampton
  1-0
  St. Mary's Stadium
•  
  vs
  Ipswich Town Ipswich Town
  3-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Millwall Millwall
  1-1
  The Den
•  
  vs
  Oxford United Oxford United
  3-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  vs
  Middlesbrough Middlesbrough
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Portsmouth Portsmouth
  1-0
  Fratton Park
•  
  vs
  Sheffield Wednesday Sheffield Wednesday
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  vs
  Coventry Coventry
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  QPR QPR
  2-0
  Loftus Road Stadium
•  
  vs
  West Bromwich Albion West Bromwich Albion
  1-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Norwich City Norwich City
  2-1
  Carrow Road
•  
  @
  Birmingham City Birmingham City
  1-1
  St Andrew's Trillion Trophy Stadium
•  
  vs
  Wrexham Wrexham
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  vs
  Swansea City Swansea City
  3-3
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Bristol City Bristol City
  1-0
  Ashton Gate
•  
  vs
  Hull City Hull City
  2-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  @
  Watford Watford
  2-0
  Vicarage Road
•  
  vs
  Blackburn Blackburn
  3-1
  Bramall Lane
•  
  vs
  Preston North End Preston North End
  3-2
  Bramall Lane

Knockout

•  
  vs
  Mansfield Town Mansfield Town
  4-3
  Bramall Lane

•  
  @
  Derby County Derby County
  2-1
  Pride Park Stadium