| Sep 18 | | 125 | Rapids 1, Earthquakes 1Final | Casey's late penalty kick lifts Rapids into draw |
| Sep 23 | | 5 | Earthquakes 1, Rapids 1Final | Earthquakes 1, Rapids 1 |
| Sep 27 | | 5 | Earthquakes 2, D.C. United 1Final | Earthquakes 2, United 1 |
| Oct 3 | | | Red Bulls 0, Earthquakes 1Final | Earthquakes avoid elimination, blank Red Bulls |
| Oct 7 | | | FC Dallas 2, Earthquakes 1Final | Cunningham's late goal boosts Dallas' playoff push |
| Oct 10 | | | Earthquakes 1, Toronto FC 1Final | Toronto FC settles for draw, hurts playoff chances |
| Oct 17 | | | Earthquakes 2, Chivas USA 2Final | Chivas takes over first place in West with draw |
| Oct 24 | | 5 | Earthquakes 0, Galaxy 2Final | Galaxy clinch West with 2-0 win over Earthquakes |
 | |
