| Sep 20 | | | Crew 2, Fire 2Final | Schelotto's 2 goals rally Crew to tie with Fire |
| Sep 26 | | | Toronto FC 2, Fire 2Final | Toronto FC 2, Fire 2 |
| Oct 2 | | 20 | Fire 0, Galaxy 1Final | Galaxy beat Fire, take lead in Western Conference |
| Oct 17 | | | Fire 0, Revolution 0Final | Fire, Revolution waste opportunities with 0-0 draw |
| Oct 22 | | 15 | Chivas USA 0, Fire 1Final | Fire beat Chivas USA 1-0 to clinch playoff spot |
| Oct 31 | | | Fire vs. Revolution | |
| Nov 1 | | | Fire 1, Revolution 2Final | Revolution beat Fire in playoff series opener |
| Nov 7 | | 10 | Revolution 0, Fire 2Final | Fire reach Eastern Conference final, blank Revs |
 | |
