| Sep 20 | | | Crew 2, Fire 2Final | Schelotto's 2 goals rally Crew to tie with Fire |
| Sep 26 | | | Galaxy 0, Crew 2Final | Crew extend MLS-record home unbeaten streak to 24 |
| Oct 3 | | 5 | Sounders FC 1, Crew 0Final | Sounders end Crew's 24-game home unbeaten run |
| Oct 10 | | 5 | Crew 1, Revolution 0Final | Crew beat Revs, clinch first in East |
| Oct 17 | | | Crew 0, D.C. United 1Final | United boost playoff hopes with 1-0 win over Crew |
| | | | Revolution 1, Crew 0Half | Revolution earn playoff spot, beat Crew 1-0 in finale |
| Oct 31 | | 5 | Crew 0, Real Salt Lake 1Final | Salt Lake blanks defending MLS Cup champion Crew |
| Nov 5 | | | Real Salt Lake 3, Crew 2Final | Real Salt Lake eliminates Columbus |
 | |
