Royals
Indians
3 - 4 Final/10
  for this game

Choo's liner hits gull, gives Indians 4-3 win

Jun 12, 2009 - 3:59 AM CLEVELAND(AP) -- Coco Crisp thought he still had a chance to get to Shin-Soo Choo's bouncing base hit. A bird beat him to it.

The ball flattened a low-flying gull in the 10th inning and rolled past Kansas City's center fielder and Mark DeRosa scored from second base without a throw to give the Cleveland Indians a 4-3 win over the Royals on Thursday night.

"Crazy things happen in this game," Crisp said after Shin-Soo Choo's line single over the second-base bag clipped the wing of one of hundreds of birds that buzz the ballpark. "It was hit so sharply, I felt like I had a chance," Crisp said. "You never know what the heck is going to happen."

The stunned bird flopped around for a few seconds before finally flying off.

Just another wild win at Progressive Field.

"I didn't see it, but I'll take it," Choo said.

Two years ago, a swarm of bugs rattled New York Yankees pitcher Joba Chamberlain in the AL division series, helping the Indians rally.

The bugs, common near the lakefront in late spring, returned a few weeks ago, and for the past few weeks, flocks of gulls have flown around feeding off them, as well as scraps of food tossed by fans.

"I guess the bugs brought the birds with that whole nature thing," Crisp said. "I'd rather have the birds, to be honest."

DeRosa opened the inning with a single off Kyle Farnsworth (1-4) - his third single along with two walks in five times up.

Victor Martinez then walked and Choo lined a 1-0 pitch over second and off the gull. The collision changed the ball's path just enough to redirect it past Crisp all the way to the wall as DeRosa scored easily and the Indians mobbed Choo to celebrate the win.

Choo was 0-for-4 with three strikeouts when he came up with two on and none out.

"When I got in the batter's box, I thought they would want me to bunt, but I appreciated they let me hit away," Choo said. "I saw the birds. I've seen them for weeks and been worried maybe 200 of them would be flying and one would get hit when I was trying to field a ball. Then what would I do?"

Matt Herges (2-0) worked the top of the 10th, allowing one hit. The right-hander has not allowed a run in his last 10 2-3 innings.

Cleveland moved out of last place in the AL Central, a half game ahead of the Royals, who have lost 23 of 30 since leading the division by three games on May 7.

"If we don't make errors the first day and today, we should sweep this series," Royals manager Trey Hillman said after Kansas City committed two errors on one play that helped Cleveland come back from a 3-1 deficit.

Royals starter Zach Greinke left with a 3-1 lead and one out in the eighth. Reliever John Bale got Choo to hit a potential double-play grounder, but the Royals started tossing the ball around wildly.

With DeRosa on second and Martinez on first, Choo's bouncer was fielded by first baseman Billy Butler, whose throw to shortstop Tony Pena forced Martinez. But Pena's return throw was in the dirt and got past Butler for an error that allowed DeRosa to score with a head-first slide. Meanwhile, second baseman Alberto Callaspo retrieved the ball and threw wide of home, sending Choo to second.

Jhonny Peralta followed with a high drive off the left-field wall that just missed being a homer, but easily scored Choo.

"When I got on base, things happened," Choo said. "I need to get on base more."

Greinke, coming off his worst start of the season, allowed three runs and six hits over 7 1-3 innings - matching his season-high pitch count at 116.

The right-hander won his first six starts and had an astounding 0.40 ERA on May 4. Then the Royals went just 2-4 in his next six outings, including a 9-3 loss at Toronto on Friday in which Greinke gave up five runs.

Miguel Olivo hit his third homer in three games, a solo shot off reliever Luis Vizcaino to make it 3-1 in the top of the eighth.

Martinez put Cleveland ahead 1-0 with an RBI single in the third.

The Royals went ahead in the fifth by scoring twice against starter Jeremy Sowers. David DeJesus had a run-scoring double and later scored Butler's grounder.

Sowers gave up two runs and six hits over five innings. Eight of the first nine outs registered by the left-hander were on grounders. He has a 2.14 ERA in four outings including three starts since being recalled from the minors May 23.

NOTES: Indians closer Kerry Wood made his 300th career appearance, striking out two in a perfect ninth. ... Royals 2B Alberto Callaspo went 1 for 5 and was 7 for 13 (.538) with his first career grand slam in the three-game series. ... Callaspo has hit .336 (46 for 137) overall in night games this season. ... Indians LHP Scott Lewis, sidelined since April 11 with a strained left elbow made his first rehab start in the minors for Class A Lake County. He struck out three over three hitless innings.






  • 155
    roots
    MattDOOM777 Added 5 roots

    Royals 3, Indians 4  Final/10Jun 12 5:18 AM
  • 150
    roots
    auksimoraun Added 5 roots

    Royals 3, Indians 4  Final/10Jun 11 11:01 PM


  • AL
    FINAL 10
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
    - - - - - - - - -
    KANSAS CITY 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 1 0
    CLEVELAND 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 2 0
    10 R H E
    -- - - -
    KANSAS CITY 0 3 9 1
    CLEVELAND 1 4 9 1 (FINAL 10)

    BATTERIES: KAN

    Jun 11 10:27 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    SINGLE BY SHIN-SOO CHOO SCORED MARK DEROSA.
    FINAL SCORE: CLEVELAND 4, KANSAS CITY 3

    Royals 3, Indians 4  Bot 10, 0 OutsJun 11 10:27 PM
  • 145
    roots
    RUWTbot Added 47 roots (Extra Innings)

    Royals 3, Indians 3  Top 10, 0 OutsJun 11 10:06 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    DOUBLE BY JHONNY PERALTA SCORED SHIN-SOO CHOO.
    SITUATION: 2 RUNS IN, J PERALTA ON SECOND, 2 OUT
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 3
    CLEVELAND 3 BOTTOM, 8TH
    DUE UP FOR CLEVELAND: J BARFIELD (.417, 0 HR, 2 RBI)

    Royals 3, Indians 3  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:43 PM
  • 98
    roots
    RUWTbot Added 43 roots (Close Finish)

    Royals 3, Indians 3  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:43 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    ERROR BY TONY PENA ALLOWED MARK DEROSA TO SCORE.
    SITUATION: 1 RUN IN, S CHOO ON SECOND, 2 OUT
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 3
    CLEVELAND 2 BOTTOM, 8TH
    DUE UP FOR CLEVELAND: J PERALTA (.254, 0-FOR-3)

    Royals 3, Indians 2  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:41 PM
  • 55
    roots
    RUWTbot Added 35 roots (Close Finish)

    Royals 3, Indians 2  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:41 PM
  • 20
    roots
    Yankee82 Added 5 roots

    Royals 3, Indians 1  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:35 PM
  • 15
    roots
    senorpepr Added 10 roots

    Royals 3, Indians 1  Bot 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:29 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    SOLO HOME RUN BY MIGUEL OLIVO (8) TO LEFT WITH 2 OUT IN THE
    8TH OFF GREG AQUINO.
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 3, CLEVELAND 1
    DUE UP FOR KANSAS CITY: W BLOOMQUIST (.281, 0-FOR-3)

    Royals 3, Indians 1  Top 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:28 PM
  • 5
    roots
    RUWTbot Took away 35 roots

    Royals 3, Indians 1  Top 8, 0 OutsJun 11 9:28 PM
  • 40
    roots
    RUWTbot Added 35 roots (Close Finish)

    Royals 2, Indians 1  Bot 7, 0 OutsJun 11 9:10 PM
  • 5
    roots
    #1 Cards Fan Added 5 roots

    Royals 2, Indians 1  Bot 5, 0 OutsJun 11 8:51 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    GROUND OUT BY BILLY BUTLER SCORED DAVID DEJESUS.
    SITUATION: 2 RUNS IN, C CRISP ON THIRD, 1 OUT
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 2
    CLEVELAND 1 TOP, 5TH
    DUE UP FOR KANSAS CITY: J GUILLEN (.259, 0-FOR-2)

    Royals 2, Indians 1  Top 5, 0 OutsJun 11 8:31 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    DOUBLE BY DAVID DEJESUS SCORED TONY PENA.
    SITUATION: 1 RUN IN, D DEJESUS ON SECOND, 0 OUT
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 1
    CLEVELAND 1 TOP, 5TH
    DUE UP FOR KANSAS CITY: C CRISP (.223, 0-FOR-2)

    Royals 1, Indians 1  Top 5, 0 OutsJun 11 8:23 PM


  • AL
    AT CLEVELAND - SCORING UPDATE
    SINGLE BY VICTOR MARTINEZ SCORED LUIS VALBUENA.
    SITUATION: 1 RUN IN, V MARTINEZ ON FIRST, M DEROSA ON THIRD, 2 OUT
    CURRENT SCORE: KANSAS CITY 0
    CLEVELAND 1 BOTTOM, 3RD
    DUE UP FOR CLEVELAND: S CHOO (.289, 0-FOR-1)

    Royals 0, Indians 1  Bot 3, 0 OutsJun 11 7:53 PM